Packing tractors

Spread 6 inches or less when you can (Holmes & Muck).

Estimated pack

12.6 lb DM/ft³

Average tractor weight20,000 lb
Tractor-packing equivalents2.00
Packing factor280
Average depth12.0 ft
Wet density at 35% DM36.0 lb/ft³
Ruppel 180-day DM loss18.0%

Below 14 lb DM/ft³. In the 1999 Wisconsin example, thinning layers, adding weight or adding a pack tractor raised density toward the target.

The packing factor

Holmes and Muck (1999) built a packing factor from the time-weighted average tractor weight (W, lb), unpacked layer thickness (L, inches), packing-time equivalents (N), dry-matter fraction (DM) and delivery rate (C, wet tons per hour):

PF = (W ÷ L) × 12 × N × DM ÷ C

Estimated dry-matter density, in lb/ft³, is (8.5 + 0.0155 × PF) × (0.818 + 0.0136 × average depth in feet). Average depth is the mean of the wall height and the center height. The ×12 converts layer thickness from inches to feet so the published worked example (PF = 140, 10.5 lb DM/ft³) holds.

The regression explained only about 18% of the variation in their bunker survey, so treat the result as a planning estimate, not a measured core density. Ruppel's 180-day loss table is interpolated beside the result: 16.8% at 14 lb DM/ft³, 15.1% at 16 lb, 10% at 22 lb.

Frequently asked questions

What packing density should I aim for?
A common target is at least 14 lb of dry matter per cubic foot (UNL, Wisconsin, Cornell). UNL Beef often cites 15 lb, or about 45 lb as-fed at typical moisture. Below 14 lb, Ruppel’s work (cited by Holmes and Muck) shows dry-matter losses around 17–20% over 180 days.
How do I raise density?
The 1999 Wisconsin example starts at 10.5 lb with 12-inch layers. Cutting layers to 6 inches raised it to 12.6 lb; adding 6,000 lb to each tractor got close to 14 lb. You can also add a pack tractor, slow the delivery rate, or pack longer.

Other calculators

Sources

  1. Holmes & Muck, University of Wisconsin: Factors Affecting Bunker Silo Densities (April 12, 1999)
  2. Ruppel, K.A. 1992. Effect of bunker silo management on hay crop nutrient management. M.S. thesis, Cornell University (DM loss by density, cited in Holmes & Muck 1999)
  3. UNL Beef: Silage Considerations (packing target of about 15 lb DM/ft³)

Estimates for planning. Density, moisture and shrink vary with the crop, packing and weather. Don't rely on these figures for insurance claims, inventories or a sales contract. Methodology. Sister site: grainshrink.com for grain moisture shrink and bin capacity.