Cattle pencil shrink versus actual shrink
Pay weight, sale-barn bids, overnight stands and why the highest $/cwt is not always the best check.
In a cattle sale, the highest price per hundredweight is not always the most money. Shrink — weight that is not paid, or that walks off between the farm and the scale — can more than erase a higher bid.
Pencil shrink versus actual shrink
Pencil shrink is a percentage taken off the scale weight to get a pay weight, used in lieu of an overnight stand without feed and water. Pay weight = live weight × (1 − shrink). Beef Cattle Handbook BCH-8020 tabulates the effect: a $90 offer with 4% pencil shrink is $86.40 per hundredweight on the live weight, before commission.
Actual shrink is weight the animal loses. Early losses are mostly gut fill (excretory shrink) and come back quickly on feed and water. Longer hauls add tissue shrink, which takes longer to recover. BCH-8020 cites about 2.5–3% overnight for fat cattle on concentrate, about 4% for cattle on grass, pulp or silage, and an Iowa feeder-cattle study of about 0.61% per 100 miles in transit.
Don't pay shrink twice
The same publication warns that pencil shrink on top of an early-morning haul after an overnight stand is a second shrink. If you already shipped cattle a long way to the scale, ask whether the bid is still taking a full pencil shrink.
The cattle shrink calculator compares two bids after shrink, commission and fees, and shows the higher offer you would need to match a no-shrink price (BCH-8020 Table 1).